Chris Cornell defends 'Idol' contender David Cook

G Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 02:13 AM EST

You're still THE BEST CHRIS CORNELL! My husband adores you so much that he even write songs inspired by your songs. I hope one day you can read his songs, even sings it! which would be a Miracle. but who knows.

daw Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 04:48 AM EST

i guess i don't see what the issue is... it WAS pointed out BEFORE the peformance that it was a cover of chris's. also, while the judges DID call david brave, i don't think they said, nor implied it was because HE arranged it. i do think david showed originality and bravery for attempting the performance, even though he didn't come up with the arrangement himself.

Beth Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 07:52 AM EST

Simon said in an interview this week that he knew where David go the arrangement. He thought David was brilliant for choosing the arrangement which was so unique. "Covering a cover is allowed as long as you pull it off" is what I think he said. I think David Cook rocks the world!

MOI Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 07:55 AM EST

Cornell is a class act. The same kind of thing happened when Daughtry did the cover of Walk the Line. Anyways, David gets kudos from the main man so lets all put it under the bridge where it belongs.

Sadie Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 08:05 AM EST

This is clearly a case of folks seeing controversy where they want to -- I didn't get the feel from the judges' critiques that they thought David did the arrangement himself. The "brave" and "brilliant" were for the risk of choosing that arrangement over the original. Furthermore, I'm a bit surprised that so many Chris Cornell fans watch Idol.

Whoa Sadie Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 08:11 AM EST

Why wouldn't Cornell fans watch Idol? I'm a fan of great singers. Cornell is definately one and so are a few of the AI alumni. You, my dear, are a music snob.

alison Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 08:37 AM EST

correct me if i'm wrong, but didn't ryan seacrest introduce david's performance as "chris cornell's version of billie jean?" if so, i don't see what the problem is...

Kevin Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 08:41 AM EST

Well, Whoa Sadie, I think the reason that Cornell fans shouldn't be watching Idol is that Idol is an abomination for people that like real music, so Cornell fans should be ashamed of themselves. If I want to see/hear bad karaoke, I'd go to the local bar. Idol, and it's annoying grip on both society and the weekly TV schedule, prevents good, scripted shows from being seen/created. It, in conjunction with Survivor, have forced us into this Reality TV quarmire that we are stuck in. That said, Go cute girl with the tattoo down your arm!

Jason Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 08:43 AM EST

This is different than when Daughtry covered "Walk the Line". Daughtry took credit for that arrangement even though it was a cover of a cover. At least this time the correct artist was acknowledged.

Gwen Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 08:50 AM EST

It's not an issue. I think the loudest whiners are the ones who are fans of the former frontrunners. Anything to keep him from reaching the top. Such children!

Thanks, Chris Cornell. And honestly, I hadn't heard of this guy until now. Now I'm a fan of his AND David Cook! See the bigger picture is all I'm sayin'!

PCat Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 08:56 AM EST

I think Cornell fans are misssing the big picture, here. I was not a fan of his before I saw David Cook do Billie Jean - I just wasn't familiar with his name or music. But after the show I started checking Cornell out on YouTube and have since bought TONS of his Soundgarden/Audioslave/Temple and solo music. I think AI brought a whole new audience to Chris Cornell. Now he's got new fans (like me).

coco puff Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 09:00 AM EST

never heard of chris before david did the cover but purchased chris' version yesterday on itunes. chris should actually be thanking david for putting him on the map for introducing him to many new listeners who, previously, had never heard of him.

Made Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 09:17 AM EST

Gwen, I agree with you 100% The outraged cries come from other contestants' fans who are watching how week after week David Cook keeps delivering stellar performances and their favourites are failing to live to their expectations.
I didn't know Chris Cornell until David sang his Billie Jean arrangement. And not only did he acknowledge who was the creator but pulled off a brilliant performance. My respect goes to Chris for his classy reaction to all this and on the other hand, I think it's a win-win situation for both David and Chris. GO DAVID COOK!

Hey Kevin Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 09:31 AM EST

It appears to me, reading alot of these posts, that Cornell has some new-found fans. Excellent! I don't look at AI as a reality show persay, more like a talent search. Nothing wrong there. I consider myself a bit of a music snob also, and make no bones about it. But the fact that I enjoy both AI and Chris Cornell doesn't make me feel the least bit 'ashamed'.
Lighten up, it's only music.

Rob Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 09:31 AM EST

Good performance, as Chris Cornell acknowledged. I will not take that away from him. However, the problem is the judges. They need to stop calling him "original." Period. As Cornell said, he used his arranagment to a T. I really think that Randy and Paula believed he came up with the arrangment. They can call him talented all over the place, but he uses other peoples' arrangments. While it makes him smart, it doesn't make him original.

denise Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 09:33 AM EST

I cannot agree more about the fact that a) AI acknowledged it was a Chris Cornell version of the song b)that those who aren't David Cook fans are looking for anything to mar him & c) I was introduced to a new artist who I now like & that artist handled this situation diplomatically! All is well again in Idoland!

Madame Knights Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 09:34 AM EST

Well if Cook is so great why can't he sing a song on his own instead of taking everyone else's arrangements?
Every week he comes out with someone else's version and yet the judges praise a cheater!
Wonder what he really is capable of, don't you?
Past Idols such as Clay, Taylor, & Carrie were rightfully praised by taking anyones song and "making" it their own.
Wake up Simon, you're being duped.

bud Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 09:38 AM EST

"Brave" is being shot at in Iraq. Singing a different version of a song on a reality show is not "brave".

Kelika Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 09:41 AM EST

I took from the judges that he was brave to do Chris' cover because typically, the AI audience wouldn't know that cover and wouldn't be open to such a song like Billie Jean being reworked into what it became with Chris' version. THAT is how I perceived what the judges said. Seriously...a rock version of Billie Jean? Many would have balked, but instead, with Chris' originality and David's circumstances to send it to millions of viewers...both have new fans and will make more money. Don't hate David for the judges not making themselves clear and David's ability to choose great arrangements (his or others) IS original..did you hear his Hello by Richie?

whereimgoing Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 09:47 AM EST

I've said it before, and I'll say it again. Even the most memorable performances (for example, Katherine McPhee singing "Somewhere Over the Rainbow") are just covers of covers. David is smart in that he goes for the more obscure arrangement that will make him stand out. But if he sucked, the performance would show that. He's coming out with on-point performances week after week, and that's the true mark of a talented performer. At the end of the day, AI is as much of a game as "Survivor", and he's playing it brilliantly!

Betty Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 09:52 AM EST

Since I listen to Country music, I didn't recognize the song or know who
Chris Cornell was. My daughter said she had heard Michael Jackson's version, but if I did I don't know it.
I thought David did a great job, no matter who did the originial

squeegee Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 09:55 AM EST

Madame Knight posted: "Well if Cook is so great why can't he sing a song on his own instead of taking everyone else's arrangements?
Every week he comes out with someone else's version and yet the judges praise a cheater!
Wonder what he really is capable of, don't you?"

We do know what he's capable of, because we've listened to his Pre-Idol music. And why is he a cheater? Every single one of the contestants are singing covers. Be rational, why don't cha?

Pat Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 09:58 AM EST

Why are there those who cannot live without making a controversy (or worse) out of everything? Take a lesson from Chris Cornell (whom I did not know)instead: admirable attitude. David is just a contestant with a great voice and knows how to deliver no matter the difficulty. Everything ever sung on Idol was written, arranged or rearranged by someone else. Should everyone only sing songs they wrote themselves? Get real!

eXPERT Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 09:59 AM EST

All of this 'originality' business is like apples and oranges. Some of these folks take chances and arrange a song like the dreaded 'Eight Days a Week' countrified version. Now THAT was brave! Remember, they have only one week to take a song and try to make it their own, not an easy task. If it were me, I'd do what Cook is doing and slightly tweak other artists arrangements. It's a compliment to the original and great publicity for them.
Fact is, Cornell will probably sell more copies of his new album because of Cook. AI is the best publicity tool there is for pimping one's music. It's good business.
So everyone's happy.

Ben Hosterman Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 10:03 AM EST

Here's the deal. When Dave Cook Sang Chris's version of Billy Jean Tuesday night it was heard and seen by more people than have seen Chris Cronell perform in the past decade! Maybe longer! He wasn’t on the radar before Tuesday night. Of course Chris is not upset about Dave covering his "song" on the most watched tv show in America right now. He undoubtedly is seeing a spike in his iTunes sales and media attention! Same for Lionel Richie. Same for Doxology. Dave Cook is bringing songs and artists back into our conscious that were for the most part dead in the current music scene.

Marcie Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 10:06 AM EST

Then Mr. Simon C. should not be saying at the end of a performance, "What an original and unique presentation to David C."..He should be tanking the real original music-maker - Chris Cornell

Marcie Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 10:06 AM EST

Then Mr. Simon C. should not be saying at the end of a performance, "What an original and unique presentation to David C."..He should be thanking the real original music-maker - Chris Cornell

mary Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 10:06 AM EST

"Ditto" on all those who never heard of Chris...I too had never heard of him. I never heard that version. I do now and I loved David's take on it, and also noticed IT WAS NOT T for T..
David's still sounded different than Chris.They both sounded great, but the singing of it was way different.

Katherine Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 10:10 AM EST

Maybe they will sing it together on the finale like Chris Daughtry sang with the lead singer of Live.

Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 10:14 AM EST

May I ask how old you people are that have never heard of Chris Cornell?

squeegee Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 10:21 AM EST

Marcie, watch the judges' comments again on youtube. Simon didn't say "original". He said it was "brave" because it could either have been "insane or amazing". It was Randy who used the word "original". Am not sure about Paula, maybe she did so too, but what I remember is something about "pushing boundaries", but that's about having the balls to try something so different on the Idol stage.

Asia'hhhhhh Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 10:26 AM EST

most awesome!

bas Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 10:29 AM EST

I, too, am surprised at the number of people commenting that they didn't know who Chris Cornell was - but then, I'm significantly older than the Idol target viewer! While I'm not a great fan of this style of music, I can appreciate the fact that David Cook looks and sounds more professional on stage than any of the other constestants - even Carly (she of the previous major label deal).

FanofBoth Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 10:37 AM EST

Just bought Chris's solo album thanks to David Cooke's cover of the cover (that was introduced as such)...thank you Chris AND David.

Rhonda Cook Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 10:37 AM EST

This is all totally ridiculous. I don't understand how people can be so cruel. David did an amazing job of Billy Jean. He has done a stellar performance week after week. After all its not the contestants fault they have to stick to a theme. If David could, believe you me he would sing his own song. He has written and sang his own songs before Idol, and he will long after. Give him a chance you people bashing him have no idea what he is capable of. In my opinion he is Brilliant!!!!!!!

barbara Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 10:38 AM EST

to Jason.you stand corrected.Chris Daughtry did indeed give credit to Live for his take on the song,they just chose not to air that part in the before the performance interview.

Marlene Dodson Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 10:42 AM EST

I remember when David's song was over, Simon made the comment that he knew who's version he sang or something to that effect. Marlene

Dalton Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 10:44 AM EST

I happen to be 46 (for the person who asked). I knew of Soundgarden and even Audioslave from the radio. I always liked their songs but never bought their music. I certainly didn't know the lead singer by name until now. When I recently (because of AI) searched for him on iTunes, I was reminded of just how many of his (and all of his band's) songs I knew and liked - and yes, bought and downloaded this time. Am I a brand new fan? Not really. But David Cook made me take a closer look at ALL of Chris Cornell's work. David Cook's music made a middle-aged person with disposable income re-discover Chris Cornell. How is that bad for Chris Cornell??? And BTW, check out Cornell's hits on iTunes and YouTube. I'm not the only person taking another look.

barbara Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 10:45 AM EST

the song was awesome and Chris Cornell is an awesome artist.

barbara Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 10:46 AM EST

the song was awesome and Chris Cornell is an awesome artist.

Arleigh Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 10:54 AM EST

Really, for those who keep saying Chris Cornell should be glad David Cook sang his cover of Billie Jean don't know much about Chris Cornell. He's practically one of the gods of rock who still make relevant music. It's great new people are now learning about Chris Cornell, but to say he should be glad ebcause now his albums will sell more makes it sound like Cornell's albums never sold well. Cornell will be relevant years after AI has stopped being one.

laura Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 10:57 AM EST

I have never heard of Chris Cornell or this new arrangement of the song BUT after hearing so much about Chris I decided to 'educate' myself and read up on him. So far so good. He seems like a really down to earth great guy ... and after reading this note .... very classy.

Monita Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 11:00 AM EST

All David and Chris did now was make the song more popular ... so now Michael Jackson will have some cash going his way jajaa

for BEN H Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 11:01 AM EST

To even hint that Chris Cornell is 'for the most part dead in the music scene' is sheer ignorance. What exactly is your 'music scene' comprised of? This guy has had an album out just about every year to the present and has been constantly touring, so he's no slouch!
Check out his website and listen to his radio interview with Ryan Seacrest that aired yesterday. Very interesting and informative!

NyGvBh Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 11:09 AM EST

I agree with Sadie that this is a case of people seeing controversy where they want it to be. They think this is a crack in David Cook's proverbial armor so they are going to sieze the opportunity to bash him. I think behind each bash you will find a deluded Michael Johns or Jason Castro fan, sad that their favorite is nothing compared to David Cook. If you like a guy because he's cute, fine...but that doesn't mean you should fool yourself into thinking he's a good singer.

Ben Hosterman Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 11:37 AM EST

Don't get me wrong, Chris Cornell is awesome. But just because he's touring and releasing albums frequently doesn't mean he's on the "radar". My band has toured and released cds over 5 years but I bet you have never heard of us. My point was now that David covered Chris's cover he (Cornell) is once again in the spotlight and no doubt seeing a lot of new fans and sales of his music so of course he's not upset that Dave covered his cover of Billy Jean. It's MASSIVE FREE PUBLICITY. I’m not bagging on Chris Cornell. But even if he didn’t like the cover Dave did he would most likely keep it to himself and reap the benefits of all this new exposure and attention.

Kay Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 11:39 AM EST

I think that the people most upset are the ones that have another clear favorite on American Idol and are now worried. I love David and what he is doing and I had never looked at Chris Connell and will now, so more power to all of it. David found a cover that was more him and as long as that is known - go for it. It helps everyone and helps us know who he is. I adore him even more and am adding new songwriters.

vw Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 11:42 AM EST

the purists here just need to breathe or stop watching AI. ALL the singers sing other people's music and have year after year. they can't sing their own music. everything they do is going to be a song someone else sang and/or wrote,period. if you take offense at the judges for not choosing their words to fit your opinion you've got more problems than that. btw did any Michael Jackson fans scream about Cornell changing up his song? don't take everything so personal especially since they're not YOUR songs. if someone has a problem it should be the songwriter/ performer of the original. but since this is reality and songs/movies/tv get remade again and again just get a grip!

Ben Hosterman Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 11:56 AM EST

One more point. My comment about artist that were dead on the current scene was more directed to White Snake (day tripper) and Lionel Richie (hello) and not so much to Chris Cornell.
And as far as "WF's" comments about singing other's songs... Dave Cook is a fantastic song writer. I helped him record his solo project and if American Idol didn't confiscate all his personal music I would show you. So he's not just a puppet with a good voice or a Kereokie singer. He's the real deal. I know he toiled with going on AI in the 1st place because it can be a double edged sword if you succeed on the show. Some see it as Joke and others don't think it's fair to rise that fast when they had to do it the old fashion way. I wish nothing but the best for him. He's a great guy a good friend and a very talented musician.

izza Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 11:57 AM EST

i dont care wether michael jackson sang that song or cornell do the arrangements as long as DAVID COOK done his very best thats all i can say go DAVID you have proven the american idol that you can sing better than anyone else

Merci Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 11:59 AM EST

Took a posters advice and listened to Cornells radio interview with Ryan Seacrest yesterday morning. It's in the news section on the main page. very informative - www.chriscornell.com

consuelo leon Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 12:04 PM EST

i think david cook did a geat job i have never heard this song before till david cook sung it. cornell should be proud now he has another fan thanks to david cook keep up the goog job

jm Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 12:10 PM EST

rarely do the original "coverers" get credit: neither Katharine McPhee nor the X factor winner, Leona? something, gave credit to the amazing Eva Cassidy for her original version of Somewhere Over the Rainbow and they both took credit for copying it to the note. Perhaps that's because Eva Cassidy has passed away, but still.. give credit where credit is due!

Debi Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 12:10 PM EST

American Idol is not a songwriting competition. The contestants do not perform original material. The viewing public prefers to hear songs they are familiar with. Almost every song performed is a cover of someone else's song. What is the difference if David Cook covered this version or Michael Jackson's version as long as the credit was given?

Jen Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 12:10 PM EST

Jesus. Seacrest introduced the song as Cornell's. Let's be real here folks. It DOES NOT need to be repeated 30007 times per show.

Rhonda C. Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 12:15 PM EST

Thank You Ben in your support of David. I too know David. I my self am totally amazed how great he does every week. As you know it's not just this song they are bashing him for. What I don't understand is why? These people are shallow. They who don't believe should go on Itunes and listen to some of his music from his old band Axium band. David Cook We love You. You are the greatest talent to ever hit American Idol. You will win, than these non believers will see.

Deb in PA Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 12:20 PM EST

Like alot of others, I've never heard of Chris Cornell. I only knew the Michael Jackson version, but I loved it. David C did a great job & deserves alot of credit for the outstanding performance. As others have also noted, they are all doing cover songs. It's required. The only difference is they are supposed to make some adjustments to make it more their own & cut it down to 1:30. Some songs are more adaptable then others. So instead of bashing a contestant for doing someone's version, try listening to the actual performance. I clearly heard Ryan state it was Cornell's version. David never took credit for that. So, GROW UP PEOPLE!!!

Gracy Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 12:26 PM EST

To me, he is a sly king of cheater. He cheated three times on "Hello", "Eleanor Rigby", and "Billie Jean" using someone else's unknown versions and got all the credit. He felt guilty now that he told it was Chris's version. I wonder whose version he is going to find in Dolly Parton's week. Hmmmm...

anon Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 12:27 PM EST

I became a fan of Cornell's solo work with the theme to the last Bond movie - "You Know My Name". Previously, I only knew about Black Hole Sun (I wasn't a rocker or metal-head in the 90's). Love his current solo stuff. Ironically, I didn't like the cover of Billie Jean and thought David would get points for being original (which now I find out he hasn't earned), but the song just had a weird feel to me. I probably can't let go of the original and that is holding me back from really liking it.

Pauckets Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 12:27 PM EST

I don't see what the issue is. They announced whose version of Billie Jean it was before the song was done. These people are competitors and what the 3 judge panel says has no weight on whose going home that week. So David Cook probably tuned them out. I mean Paula's out of her mind comments and Randy's "it didn't do anything for me." are predictable. As well as Simon's bantering just to hear himself be booed doesn't mean anything at this phase of the contest. Until your standing on a stage in front of that many people in the same situation, you never know how you would react. I don't understand why EW is looking for ways to discredit these vocalists. Is it an envy issue on behalf of the writer. It's gotten to the point I don't like reading the articles because of the personal statements made. I mean has anyone looked into the writer's musical background and wether their comments are any more credible than ours? Do they have musical background or is it just another vent?

Jennifer Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 12:36 PM EST

I saw a replay of that performance -- with Ryan's and the judges' commentary -- and I didn't detect AT ALL that the judges were giving David Cook credit for the arrangement. They were only commenting on how brilliantly he performed it and how brave it was for him to sing that song in that [not-so-familiar-to-most-people] way. I've heard Chris Cornell's version, and I've heard Cook's version, and I love them both. Love the arrangement. Love the performances. Love. Love. Love.

SallyinChicago Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 12:36 PM EST

Glad to have seen the cover by David C., because honestly I had no idea who Chris Connell was or that the version was out there. That's the good thing about Idol. For us fuddy-duddys who don't listen to top 40 radio or music, it intro's us to those we don't know outside of Beyonce (who's everywhere). Just saying. Idol helps obscure artists more than hurt. And so what if it was a cover. These kids are not pros, they cannot arrange songs like the pros. They can just barely step out on the stage.

Idol Fan Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 12:37 PM EST

My beef is that the judges are always criticizing contestants for singing a song just like an original, not making it their own, and thus sounding like karaoke. Well, David sang the Cornell cover note for note, didn't make it his own and got praised for originality. I guess it's a smart strategy for David to copy unique covers of well known songs to get praise from musically ignorant judges and the unknowing public.

baobabs727 Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 12:37 PM EST

Well, David Cook is now the front runner, so I would expect that we would all pile on him now. Little David is off the hook. Of course, Mr. Sleezy will do his best to see that neither scenario comes true,right Mr. Sleezy?

Karen Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 12:38 PM EST

I love Chris Cornell's music from Audioslave and Soundgarden (both are on my iPod), but actually prefer David Cook's version of Billy Jean.

Intercede Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 12:41 PM EST

Ok, First people are supposed to take songs during that time frame or by that writer and perform them. They are already Covers. Second, this is a SINGING competition. You can not cheat on singing. Either you can sing or you can't. Unless you prove his Milly Vanilly all over again, then don't label him a cheater. Chris Cornell isn't claiming copyright infringements so why was this article even posted other than to cast a bad light on a good singer?

Ben Hosterman Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 12:44 PM EST

Grace... A "sly king of cheater"? WTF? You can't cheat when you get out there and sing your heart out. Who cares where the version came from? He’s not getting all the credit. Count the posts above that point out who wrote the song and who rearranged it and re-recorded it. I don’t think anyone at this point thinks David cheated or tried to pass this off as his own. Who cares if someone else did it like him before he sang it on AI? Can anyone posting here today argue that David Cook is not a great singer and probably the best if not one of the best in this season? I guess this comes with the territory when you're on top. Some people just have to criticize others to make up for their own shortcomings. Grace: As my older brothers used to say to me when I got annoying… “go play in the street”

fiona Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 12:46 PM EST

Guys! Chris Cornell is one of the most influential musicans of our time! I don't care that some guy on AI covered his cover... I don't even watch AI! What's great is people who never heard of Chris Cornell (living under rocks?) are finally getting exposed to some great music!

Jennifer Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 12:47 PM EST

Okay, I had to chime in one more time. This chain of comments is cracking me up. Not only does the majority of us posters not care, we clearly know that Chris Cornell was given credit and that David Cook rocked it. Nicely done, David! And, EW, find a real story to write about.

to Gracie Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 12:49 PM EST

You're a bit of an idiot, aren't you?
There are a lot of stupid people out on these boards.

Rhonda C. Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 01:01 PM EST

I totally agree, Gracie don't you have any thing else to do with your time?
You must not know what real talent is. You should be ashamed of your self. There are ton's of people who know Davids real talent. So face it girl you are way out numbered.

Snsetblaze Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 01:11 PM EST

Anyone but me want to hear David now do Michael Jackson's version? Kidding. I do love Cook but David's tenure on AI is really mirroring Chris Daughtry's. Simon initially did not want to send Daughtry through to Hollywood because of his (alleged) lack of charisma and he told Daughtry several times that he did not think America would like him. And David was told by Simon that he has no charisma and America would not like him. It took a while for Simom to be a fan of both. Daughtry was praised for being the most original contestant evern and had the same thing happen with covering someone else's version of a song although the show chose not to air the credit in Daughtry's case. It did happen more than once. Now Cook is being called the most original ever but being criticized at the same time for covering covers. His fans better watch out when we get near the top 4.

I was a Cornell fan before and am now a bigger fan. Classy guy.

Ben Hosterman Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 01:30 PM EST

OK. This wont make me popular here but I just listened to Chris Cornell's live performance of Billy Jean (From his own website) and David Cook's back to back... And I'm sorry Cornell fans but Dave's performance is better. Maybe it's not fair to compare them side by side since Dave only has to sing one song a night and Chris is singing a whole set and has to make his voice last the entire night but if your just cruising around Youtube looking for the different version's of this song... Dave's performance is Better. Stylistically, tonality, pitch, stage presence, everything. Bring on the criticism! As Simon says.. "It's just an opinion"

to karen Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 01:36 PM EST

I agree with Karen, even though I have been a big fan of Chris Cornell's (Soundgarden/Audioslave and especially his solo career, I preferred David Cooks version...also, I don't feel his cover was to a T... there are subtle nuances throughout that are different...Wise up people,David Cook is a force to be reckoned with, and I think we'll be seeing alot more of him post Idol. As for Chris, kudos to you......your a class act.

to karen Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 01:36 PM EST

I agree with Karen, even though I have been a big fan of Chris Cornell's (Soundgarden/Audioslave and especially his solo career, I preferred David Cooks version...also, I don't feel his cover was to a T... there are subtle nuances throughout that are different...Wise up people,David Cook is a force to be reckoned with, and I think we'll be seeing alot more of him post Idol. As for Chris, kudos to you......your a class act.

Sarah Hay- Smith Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 01:44 PM EST

i think that david cook needs to go mayeb he will go this week and he can not win because there are people on american idol who are better than David Cook

Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 01:47 PM EST

I dig them both
Actually, I think David Cook's spin on it was still different from Chris's arrangement, yet still Chris's arrangment, you know? I listened to both of them and they are different, both versions great.

Rodz Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 01:50 PM EST

The only reason I am watching this show is because of guys like David Cook and Michael Johns .... they are not the little Davids that all he does is swing his hips and hands ... yes he can sing but that is it. NOW Cook and Johns, they are different. Little David is pop ... that is it and I get bored listening to him. I know not to expect much from him other then yes he is a cute kid. NOW Cook and Johns, they have me wondering how they can out due each other and I hope everytime that they do a great job. For the first time ever I am voting!! For the first time ever I am making plans to watch AI ..

So if Cook did a song that has been done .... good because that is what this show is about ... to do covers. Now his job is to show everyone that he can do more then covers .. that he does have a career out there waiting to happen and he will have his OWN material.

MC Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 02:02 PM EST

Listen to the studio version of "You're the Voice", it is FANTASTIC! Support David by downloading the song from iTunes. His voice is AMAZING and the message is so inspiring and hopeful.

Ballzack Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 02:02 PM EST

Cornell is amazing and it's a great version of a classic song. He's also a good guy it would seem -- and will be substantially richer thanks to David Cook. Win win win.

MC Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 02:03 PM EST

Listen to the studio version of "You're the Voice", it is FANTASTIC! Support David by downloading the song from iTunes. His voice is AMAZING and the message is so inspiring and hopeful.

Scott B. Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 02:08 PM EST

Will you people PLEASE stop acting like David Cook put Chris Cornell on the radar. Chris Cornell is one of the most well known rock singers of all time, who has fronted two of the most successful rock bands of the last two decades. Just because some of you have never heard of him does not mean that he isn't on the radar - he is hugely popular with anyone who has spent more than ten minutes listening to rock radio over the last twenty years.

I am a David Cook fan and don't really see what all of the controversy is about here, but it is driving me nuts to see people saying that David Cook did Chris Cornell a favor. No, Chris Cornell did David Cook a favor by doing what he did with the arrangement. And David did a great job of singing it.

Iowa-ldol Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 02:22 PM EST

Listen, folks.... Bottom line up front, David sang brilliantly, it doesn't matter who's version of "Billie Jean", he sang, DAVID C. was the BEST singer of night! One side note, perhaps Paula and Randy need to listen to Ryan a little more, they totally had NO IDEA it wasn't David's arrangement! Hmmmm? Perhaps they too, are distracted by the waving hands! STOP THE INSANITY!!!!!

Nick Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 02:35 PM EST

Chris Cornell career? Dead? How people could use those words in one sentence is beyond me. His career is very much alive and he has a good fanbase. Also, to the person says that their band tours and makes CD's but no one knows who they are, that is because your CD's don't sell, and your tours aren't big. Cornell sells very well, he got one of the rare oppurtunities of singing a Bond song which is still very well praised, and overall people just love him.

Reggie Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 02:40 PM EST

Jason Posted: "This is different than when Daughtry covered "Walk the Line". Daughtry took credit for that arrangement even though it was a cover of a cover. At least this time the correct artist was acknowledged."

Actually, Mr. Daughtry has stated numerous times since he performed "Walk The Line", that it was in fact, a cover of Live's take on the song, it was even addressed in his interview package, which the producers cut.
However, even if these guys are "covering covers", it still takes guts. Not only did David Cook cover one of the most popular songs ever recorded, he performed a completely different cover of the orginal. That, in my opinion, is what makes him brave.
People get way too uppety about the things on this show. Take it for what it is: entertainment.

Jonathan Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 02:55 PM EST

Personally, it has really been bothering me how David Cook seems to be taking credit for other rockers' talents, and reeping the benefits from the judges and probably most of America with their praise and votes. He should at least have the decency to acknowledge that he is ripping off other artists and their talent. Even still, I will say that he is one of my favourites in terms of vocals and performance.

Ben Hosterman Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 02:56 PM EST

ornell wasn't in the recent national spotlight before Tuesday night. Sure he’s touring and playing shows. So are a thousand other artist that none of us know about! Yes, he fronted ONE Successful Rock band over 10 years ago. I like Audio Slave too but they didn't even come close to soundgard. So just looking at recent history David Cook, by choosing a version of Billy Jean that Cornell "COVERED" brought Cornell back into the spotlight. The new found royalties in Chris Cornells coffers should be thanks enough. Look. They probably both like what the other has done for them. Dave has now been acknowledged by Chris and Chris is in the news again. It’s about as mutual as it can get.

Nathan Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 03:00 PM EST

I find it odd that Cornell's even associating himself with this American Idol sh*t. Good on him I guess, sort of.

Angela Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 03:27 PM EST

To those who keep insisting that David "cheated", why it only him getting all the backlash? Should David A get backlashed for doing Eva Cassidy's version of Imagine? It should matter whether he did the arrangement or not. As long as he gives me chills and moves me to vote for him and buy his album, everything else is secondary. Whether you like him or not, he did give the performance of the night. We should judge him on his talent and nothing else.

Angela Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 03:29 PM EST

Jonathan, you must have some wax buildup in your ears, because he did give Chris credit. Enough with that already. Case closed.

Yo Scott B. Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 03:29 PM EST

I totally agree with you man!
And I remember the first time I heard Like a Stone and I Am the Highway. His voice hypnotized me. Those guys from Seattle, ie. Nirvana, Pearl Jam etc. all had that great meaty tone to their voices. Cornell has been in this business a long time. David Cook is getting his big break and all the power to him. Both are great talents, but Cook has a way to go to prove himself. Let's see where he's at in 10 years.

thelma Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 03:39 PM EST

there is a difference betwen covering a cover, and copying every note. david cook crossed the line by showing no originality at all.

Ben Hosterman Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 03:42 PM EST

Well said Angela and Scott B.

Suzanne Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 03:46 PM EST

1. I wonder if EW will call John Farnham to see if he thinks his song was done justice this week?

2. 30 million people know who Chris Cornell is now. Seems pretty good for Chris Cornell. (He sounds pretty good--not knocking him--just saying the cover for good for business.)

Clueless Alert Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 03:48 PM EST

Ryan mentioned it was Cornell's version BEFORE Cook even sang it. Cornell's so-called fans have selective listening or are just plain dumb.

Angela Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 03:49 PM EST

Thelma, your post makes no sense. So Syesha shouldn't be crucified for sounding like Whitney when she did "Saving All My Love For You during top 16? How is that different with David C? None

Sheesh Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 03:50 PM EST

Cook was "brave and original" because he sought out a version of the song that wasn't the original release. Duh!!! He wasn't try to allude to anyone that he had "invented" the cover. Why is there such bashing fueled by pathetic ignorance?

brenda Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 03:58 PM EST

Chris Cornell is a class act - and a great song-writer vocalist. If new fans find because of AI- good for him, and great for the fans -- but to suggest that David Cook helped Chris Cornell out - it is comments like that that make his fans angry. AI fans are so passionate all sense goes out the widow.

Sally in Houston Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 03:58 PM EST

Wow, there are actually people who know David Cook writing on this blog. Ben Hosterman-- I have no idea who you are but I think I may google your name. I am glad you are defending your friend. He is obviously extremely talented. Personally, I loved Kelly Clarkson and have not really been taken by any other Idol contestants until David Cook came along. I have been voting for him voraciously since "hello" and will continue to do so. Love his intelligence, voice, musical style and the way he delivers a song (that delivery of Hello was incredibly sexy). He also sounds very genuine in his interviews. I have no doubt that he writes his own music and will continue to showcase that. Go David Cook!!

brenda Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 04:00 PM EST

Chris Cornell is a class act - and a great song-writer vocalist. If new fans find CC because of AI- good for him, and great for the fans -- but to suggest that David Cook helped Chris Cornell out - well, it is comments like that that make his fans angry. AI fans are so passionate all sense goes out the window.

Nan. Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 04:20 PM EST

I love Cornell, and Cook for doing his rendition of the song. It takes guts to pull that off. He did it beautifully, and blew me away. I don't see what the issue of doing a cover of a cover would be. Cornell had no issues with it. Cook did it perfectly in tuned with how Cornell did.
Rock on! Give the boy credit for trying something different. He did do it well, and credit was given where it was due, in the results show. Why so many are having a hissy, is beyond me.
I want to also say, that if Jackson had done it that way to begin with, I would actually be a fan of the song back then, when HE did it. I like Cornell's version better, anyhow.

Ben Hosterman Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 04:21 PM EST

Brenda. With all due respect you don't have a clue what you're talking about. Dave Cook just brought Chris Cornell to 30 million+ Viewers. If you can't see how that helped him then you have no business making comments. Saying Dave helped Cornell this week singing this cover of a cover is in no way disparaging Chris Cornell. He obviously has a long history of making great music. But as a gigging musician and a consumer of music, Cornell hasn't been tearing up the airwaves as of late and I would bet you he is loving this new found attention and interest. Good for him. Bad for nobody. If you're an angry Cornell fan GET OVER IT! There is no harm being done by any of this! Like countless people have stated before… Credit was given where credit was due. It's a win-win for everybody but the other 8 contestants who got “out shined, out shined!”

Lisa G Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 04:27 PM EST

I think that the judges (mainly Randy and Paula) are too blame for this getting out of hand.They praised Blake last year for originality when he did 311's version of Lovesong. They need to start listening to music other than their own!

Sally in Houston Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 04:30 PM EST

Of course David Cook helped Chris Cornell out. One can't beat the exposure one gets on AI. I mean it is the number 1 show on TV. I am sure he has many fans but will ultimately have many more as a result of David's Billy Jean cover. It's no different than Seacrest saying there was a bump in sales of Beatles albums after Beatles week.

Lisa G Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 04:30 PM EST

Also, listened to both live versions and liked David C.'s better and this is coming from a huge Chris Cornell fan.
Love You Chris!

Sarah Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 04:33 PM EST

People said the same thing about Chris Daughtry's cover of Live's version of "Walk the Line." Who cares.

anti-clueless Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 04:34 PM EST

Jonathon - David Cook isn't in charge of the editing on the show. He acknowledged that his cover of Eleanor Rigby was Doxology's version, but they cut it out, and controversy ensued. It was announced that Billie Jean was Cornell's version, but the judges - Randy in particular - still gave him props for originality. Given the time constraints in which they have to choose their song, David is brilliant for knowing the best versions in advance and selecting them for the show.
Kevin - I am a huge Cornell fan, yet I shamelessly watch Idol every week. You are not the arbiter of what the rest of the world should be spending their time doing.

kellybelly Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 04:35 PM EST

Hey People,
David Cook DID do an original cover ALL his own -- "Hello" by Lionel Richie.
It's okay, I almost forgot too.
He probably needs to do it again (an original cover) so people don't forget that he can do it, and he did it before.

Question: is 'original cover' an oxymoron like 'jumbo shrimp' ?

MOI Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 04:37 PM EST

I'm a Cornell fan but I'm not all out of joint like some of you guys. David Cook is good, he's no Chris Cornell though. And I don't mind saying that I like Cook's version a little better. So what? It won't mean I like Chris's stuff any less. The guy rules!
You people are taking this stuff way too seriously. Chill and just listen to these 2 great artists do their thing!

Ben Hosterman Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 04:41 PM EST

Finally! Some sensible comments!

Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 04:59 PM EST

The difference with Daughtry singing "Walk the Line" is I don't think LIVE was credited on the show. That's why people were talking about it so much afterwards. They've learned now to credit the original performer. As long as you do, I don't see the issue.

Heather Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 04:59 PM EST

The difference with Daughtry singing "Walk the Line" is I don't think LIVE was credited on the show. That's why people were talking about it so much afterwards. They've learned now to credit the original performer. As long as you do, I don't see the issue.

Sally in Houston Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 05:14 PM EST

Good for you anti-clueless. Wise words.

Lola Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 05:22 PM EST

Come on...why should David say 'again' that he was doing Chris's cover if Ryan had already said it when he introduced him? David knew that cover was well known by Chris's fans and that it would have come out if he'd tried to make them think it was his own arrangment. David is not a fool....just one terrific talent!! I wish he would win, but he is the winner whether he does or not. It's so obvious.

AA Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 05:31 PM EST

I thought David Cook was absolutely brilliant -- one of the first performances I've ever seen on Idol that has given me shivers. As other people commented, Ryan Seacrest did mention that it was Chris Cornell's arrangement -- no need for him to say it again. Cornell is gracious -- but smart as well. After all, his version of the song will likely attract interest, perhaps from a broader range of listeners, b/c of how well it was received. And deservedly so -- Cornell has both the vocal AND instrumental chops. I hope that inspires other vocalists/musicians to put a unique spin on a cover.

probie Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 05:49 PM EST

OK - so I'm kind of "duh" musically and was amazed by this kid's song and literally cried I thought it was so good. The next day, my little brother who followed the Seattle grunge movement religiously calls me up and is using a series of 4-letter words to tell me how ticked off he was that none of the judges called the kid on it. I had no idea what he was talking about until I went on U-tube and listened to the original. My reaction is that it isn't the singer's place to tell these so-called music judges something that should have been evident. Simon knew that goofy Austrailian group that David Archaletta ripped off and if was truly the judge that he claims he is, he would have NEVER called this kid original. Score: David Cook 1 - Simon Cowell - 0.

Adam Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 06:20 PM EST

David Cook's cover of Chris Cornell's version of "Billie Jean"
was great. Gave me chills listening to it.

My only beef is in regards to how everybody keeps stating that they have
never heard of Chris Cornell before...especially coming from so-called
music enthusiasts. Has nobody ever heard of Soundgarden? Audioslave?
Jeepaz...he was the lead singer of these two very prominent bands. Get
out from under your rocks "music enthusiasts".

jen Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 07:00 PM EST

Jeez, talk about much ado about nothing. Cornell is great... but I have to confess I didn't recognize his name even though my friends and I liked Soundgarden in high school. I frankly didn't know WHAT he had been doing since but I intend to find out! As for David Cook, to say he is a cheater is LOONEY. What more can you do but give credit...which was done. The show manufactures these "controversies" for ratings. Adding credit here, cutting out credit there, making sure the judges say stupid inflammatory things. ESPECIALLY since that ballroom show is gaining on them.

Deborah Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 07:12 PM EST

David Cook was "brave" to do a song that was arranged and performed by Chris. I think it is an insult to Chris to say he was not brave. I don't know of any other idol past or present who could pull off a Chris Cornell arrangement/song so perfectly.
And David is an "original" in the AI context. He is very good at picking songs AND arrangements that show his awesome vocal ability. After all it is a SINGING competition.The Idols only have seven days to pick a song, often in a genre they are not familiar with, learn it and record it for itunes. Plus all the other stuff they have them do. When would they have time to arrange their songs? It is a win win situation for AI, David Cook and Chris Cornell. Thank you Chris Cornell for being an adult and showing appreciation for an unknown kid in a singing contest. I have been a fan of Chris Cornell ever since Soundgarden and after his classy reaction I am now a bigger fan and will definitely get his new CD

Cindi Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 07:19 PM EST

I thought this performance was excellent. He said it was Chris Cornell's version and Chris said he did a good job. However he didn't sing it note for note. I have listened to both and David definitely put his own spin on it. David has a much clearer voice and much much bigger range. I don't think Chris could have hit the big note. I am a fan of his music though. I'm not sure why everyone keeps bringing up this Doxology thing. They are a band from Seattle that had no national coverage. How would he have even found the version in the first place? There are a lot of bands who sing "Eleanor Rigby" and many different bands singing it on YouTube. Many of them sound alot alike. Doxology got their free publicity so give it a rest. He completely changed "Hello". That was great. It sounded nothing like Incubus which was very soft and slow and sounded more like Lionel. Not even close. David Cook is an original. He knows what he can do and makes good choices. This guy is already a star. Love him!!

Get it Straight Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 07:27 PM EST

For once and for all, Chris Daughtry acknowledged that he was doing a cover of Live's Walk the Line in the pre-performance TAPED interview. It was cut out of the segment they showed on Idol. Stop perpetrating a falsehood.

KT Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 08:08 PM EST

All of this complaining is just plain stupid. David Cook is an amazing singer, and just because he is smart enough to search for covers of songs that fits his voice he is getting criticized. As the newly emerged frontrunner, of course people are going to find things to pick at him about. Anyway, when I heard he was going to be singing Billie Jean, I was a little nervous for him. I'm a huge fan of his since the Top 24 week and I didn't want to see him falter. But he didn't, he was amazing and like a poster said before me, his cover was definately not note for note of Chris Cornell's version. I think David is brilliant, and the best talent AI has ever seen. I hope he goes all the way! I'm voting for him!

Frosty Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 08:46 PM EST

It's a "SINGING" competition. Not a "WHOSE SONG ARE YOU COPYING" competition. The whole basis of the show is doing covers. To much drama over nothing.

Justin Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 08:50 PM EST

Chris has a great attitude. I am glad he embraces Davids performance of billie jean on idol. It honors both Jackson and Cornell to be performed so beautifully. David and Chris jamming someday I hope? We love you Chris!

Josh Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 09:02 PM EST

"Hello" - Brandon Boyd
"Eleanor Rigby" - Doxology
"Billie Jean" - Chris Cornell

What's next?

David C is cunning, cocky, roguish, smug and very original. America! Do you want that kind of American idol?

catseye Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 09:27 PM EST

Syesha- Earth wind and fire covering The Beatles
David A- David Foster covering John Farnham
David A- Eva Cassidy covering John Lennon
Carly- Celine Deon covering whoever wrote the Drive All Night song

All of the above were never credited on the show, yet DC does and ends up in a firestorm.

So do I need to add more from this season or the previous 6. They all are singing either covers or covers of covers. I don't get the problem. If there is an issue take it up with the judges, not DC. He gave credit and has no control over what Randy and Paula say.

Zach Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 10:39 PM EST

I actually liked David Cook's performance, but the judges have to get a clue and stop calling him original. He is smart for choosing covers that most people don't know, but he is certainly not original. As Chris Cornell said, David followed Cornell's arrangement to a T, including the vocal nuances. I want to see David actually sing a song using an arrangement that people know instead of always using lesser known arranagements. If he keeps doing what he is doing, it is going to turn a lot of people off. But if he can do versions we all know and do a good job, he may actually deserve to win.

Karen Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 10:46 PM EST

First of I'm the biggest Chris Cornell fan. Have been since Soundgarden. His voice soars. Yes I watch American Idol. CC sang this version of BJ at his concert last year. All the kids have talent but because they have to sing covers and have a short list to choose from kudos to them. The contest shows who rises to the challege, and can really sing. It's crazy to think the kids can learn and perform a song in two days let alone arrange one. A cover is a cover. Kudos to David Cook who is a true indie rocker exposing middle america to great artists like Chris Cornell, Incubus, and Doxology. If they don't get mentioned it's probably in the editing. but because of the internet they will be discovered and mentioned. Kudos to my man Chris for responding like a true artist. Just heard his next album is being produced by Timbaland. Cornell believes a good song is a good song. Unlike many pop artist Chris could win idol if he entered because he is so talented!!!

Lola Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 10:50 PM EST

Yes, Ryan did introduce it as Cornell's version before the performance, but to be honest, it was said as a bit of a throwaway amidst a throng of screaming girls. The classy thing would have been for David to have acknowledged Chris when the judges were banging on about David's creativity and originality. This is not to say that David Cook's performance was bad by any means, just that if he was such a fan of Chris Cornell's version he should have enough respect to give credit where credit is due.

Lola Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 10:50 PM EST

Yes, Ryan did introduce it as Cornell's version before the performance, but to be honest, it was said as a bit of a throwaway amidst a throng of screaming girls. The classy thing would have been for David to have acknowledged Chris when the judges were banging on about David's creativity and originality. This is not to say that David Cook's performance was bad by any means, just that if he was such a fan of Chris Cornell's version he should have enough respect to give credit where credit is due.

Shut Up Already Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 11:03 PM EST

All U people bashing David Cook..calling Chris Cornell a musical genious..after all is said & done, "Billie Jean" IS STILL A MICHAEL JACKSON SONG. Don't be bashing an Idol contestant that did a cover from another person, whom did a cover. Where's the praise for Michael Jackson? I mean, it IS his song. So what, Cornell changed the arrangement. Also, telling people 2 get out from underneath rocks because those have never heard of Chris Cornell..sorry to break it 2 ya, but NOT EVERYONE LISTENS 2 YOUR KIND OF MUSIC. That doesn't make people ignorant because some never stopped 2 listen 2 Cornell in "Audioslave" or "Soundgarden." David Cook did an amazing job, whether he took some arrangement from Cornell. All the contestants on Idol do cover songs, that's what the show is for, U don't go on Idol singing your own music that you've written. Michael Johns didn't do anything interesting with Queen's "We Will Rock You" & "We are the Champions." Everyone is just making a big deal out of NOTHING.

Christopher Crespo Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 11:15 PM EST

I am not here to make a comment but will hold my self responsible and liable for making THIS STATEMENT as

truthfully (and as objectively) as I know how in basis of my board knowledge concerning legal issues, the music

industry in general, and out of a matter of rather direct personal opinions.

First thing, when it comes to the media (especially the enterianment industry media) they are as derivatory as they

come. THEY ask derviatory questions that aren't direct or would say how Chris Cornell feels (in feeling) they would

ask a ridiciously board question as, "In general, do you find anything disingenuous about Idol contestants doing

covers of covers?"... this isn't telling me Chris Cornell's true feelings and reacion to what a deceptively "SO

CALLED big fan" David has done to steal the glory from an incretable musician that currently plays in the band Audioslave.

Christopher Crespo Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 11:18 PM EST

hat is American Idol as a company

is going to do about it EVEN IF Chris Cornell would say it would be relentlessly wrong. Absolutely nothing, you

know why because they are doing buisness and restrainting contestants would obviously mean lower revenue because there

would be less variety of contestants and less competition (because of the new restraint standard) thus making

making the show less interesting for viewers, which THUS in turn means less money coming back in for the business.

In terms of this David Cook, Chris Cornell needs REALIZE WHAT THIS GUY IS TRYING TO PLOT SOMETHING HERE. Let us

just think about this for a second... hmm, let's see he is a low life motherf*cker that is trying to make it big,

GET A CONTRACT ESTABILISHED BY AMERICAN IDOL AND GUESS WHAT record this same song that Chris Cornell has put time

in to create and copyright it under his name and claim that it was his! HELLO ARE WE WAKING UP YET!?!

Christopher Crespo Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 11:20 PM EST

It is indeed

a temporary glory that can amount to a permanent glory in terms of copyrighting this average tofu hasn't orginally

produced. Going back to the orginal intent of this paragraph, What the hell kind of question is "Where you

flattered by the performance?", I understand Chris Cornell is protraying acts of good sportmanship and fairplay but

there is nothing fair to what this snake has done. Chris Cornell NEEDS TO WAKE UP and realize that is song is under

HIS patient and needs to understand that it would be best to get his work under some type of legal protection

BEFORE he samples his music out to the public like that. Just a word to the wise coming from one of your loyal fans

;). Throwing myself back to the source of my reasoning and to this weak and indirect question coming from a MUCH

NEUTRAL enterainment media they call EW.COM. What the hell kind of question is this,

Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 11:20 PM EST

"Where you flattered by his

performance?" YOU guys already know Chris Cornell is going to say nice things about the performance because Chris

Cornell is a PROFESSIONAL not some dog off the street (from which I CAN EVEN TELL YOU there are more TRUTHFUL DOGS

out there then professional ones might I remind). DO YOU SERIOUSLY think Chris Cornell has the time to reallly sit

down and think about whether he was TRULY flattered about the performance or not. Come on EVEN the common folk can

anticpate what the vocalist and musician is going to say.

Christopher Crespo Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 11:22 PM EST

F COURSE he is going to be flattered and arroused by the

performance. For one, Chris Cornell is a professional so professionals always play along with the media to preserve

reputation outside the loyal fans base he is close to. Second, he doesn't have the time to answer questions

because the man truly has a purpose he continues to dedicate himself to this VERY DAY (being that he has his

personal and purposeful reason to do so might I had). Finally, this is "OUT" of respect if you know what I mean in

regards to another obviously produced question coming from an another obvious undeserving gaint enterainment press

that doesn't deserve to be where it is at pretty much because, like all enterainment media, is popular because the

target market goes to people who aren't as educated and MOST IMPORTANTLY it fails to accept personal responsiblity

for what they write and in such a case such as this one,

P Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 11:23 PM EST

Chris Cornell did a cover version of Michael Jackson's "Billie Jean." The song BELONGS to Michael Jackson. Whether David sung it, or Chris sung it, it doesn't matter, it's an MJ song. The song was WRITTEN, ARRANGED, & COMPOSED by MJ. The song is based on true circumstances. Little would any of you know, MANY people have done covers & remixes of "Billie Jean," but I guess none of you knew that. Artists have changed "Billie Jean" into a jazzy song, a rock song, a fast dance song, & so on. David Cook took an arrangement from a guy that covered Michael Jackson, the only thing Cornell did was change the arrangement of the song, slowed it down, used grittier vocals, and put a rock-alternative instrumentation on it. Lets face it though folks, don't give all the credit to Cornell. "Billie Jean" is a Michael Jackson song & will ALWAYS be a Michael Jackson song. Not every1 knows Chris Cornell, don't bash them. There are mant great old artists out there, some just choose not 2 listen to Cornell.

To Christopher Crespo Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 11:24 PM EST

What are you on and where can I get some...seriously.

Gimme break Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 11:31 PM EST

There is absolutely NOTHING original about getting up on stage and recreating, note-for-note, someone else's artistic vision of an arrangement THAT distinctive. It was like karaoke impersonation night. When the judges were falling all over themselves about how brave and original David Cook was to perform that song, he absolutely should have at least MENTIONED his debt of gratitude to the Chris Cornell for even making that possible. It came off as sneaky, cynical and more than a little obnoxious. I never saw the big attraction to the guy in the first place, but now my skin crawls every time I see him. UGH.

Lola Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 11:37 PM EST

P- Yes, there have been other covers of Billie Jean, but the point is that David Cook specifically performed Chris Cornell's arrangement. The argument is not that he did a poor job of it, but that it would have been more respectful as an artist to recognize another artist instead of soaking up all the praise for himself. I still think that he is a good singer and by no means wish to bash him, but what he did was bad form.

To Cocopuff Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 11:38 PM EST

Are you for real? Chris Cornell should be THANKING David Cook? Yes, I'm sure this is exactly what a musician like Cornell truly wants: a bunch of wannabe rockers downloading a pilfered piece of his art off iTunes. That "hey, if he's cool enough for American Idol, then he's cool enough for me!!" attitude would be seriously funny if it wasn't too nauseating for words.

mc Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 11:39 PM EST

I am a long time Chris Cornell fan. I've followed his career for around 17 years. And even though initially I was somewhat dismayed & frustrated by the judge's reactions the other night, I now think that it's been a wonderful week for Chris Cornell and David Cook.

Just reading here how many people have taken a new interest in Cornell and some even buying his music can only be a positive thing.

There is no need now to be so angry about it. Ryan Seacrest made it very clear during the elimination show it was Chris's arrangement. It is a winning situation for everybody.

Good luck to Chris and good luck to David. I hope he wins. :)

Let's Get Real Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 11:50 PM EST

Syesha is a huge Whitney Houston fan, and if she got up there and sang a note-for-note "arrangment" of "I Will Always Love You," complete with overwrought oversinging, she would not be hailed by the judges as "original" or "brave." Same with Brooke, plunking out a note-perfect "tribute" to Carole King on the piano. And Carly has already been told to stop channeling Celine. The only reason the judges are pimping David Cook so hard is because they - especially Simon - completely missed the boat with Chris Daughtry, and they're trying to save face now. How Cook handled himself was seven different kinds of shady and everybody knows it.

Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 11:52 PM EST

Don't forget Chris Cornell was also in Temple of the Dog, who had a couple of great songs too.

Vader Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 11:53 PM EST

I'm going to be blunt and say that those who whined about David being a copycat, are idiots. AI performers ARE REQUIRED to sing songs covered by other artistes. And if David chose this version over the original, that's entirely his choice. I understand that some fans are upset that the judges mistakenly praised David for being original; if that's the case well that's hardly David's fault is it? Moreover, Ryan Seacrest already mentioned that it was Chris Cornell's version. So please stop the whining. Lastly, some of us have never heard Cornell's version (myself included), so to us it doesn't even matter! In the end if the performance is great, who the hell cares if it's an imitation? If it's a poor imitation, it's a flop, and if it's a good imitation it's a hit, as in David's case. So once again, quit whining morons. :)

Chris Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 11:56 PM EST

You know what I am wasting my time... The album as already been produced. I had to re-read the article again to comperhend, I over-reacted and I am terribly sorry. I am a big Audioslave fan and to see anything legally unjust going against to such an awesome band... well one can only help to react in rather direct frustration. The general population is right, HIS VERSION of "Billie Jean" has been legally produced and copyrighted so AS LONG AS THAT version or make of "Billie Jean" is legally under his arm EVEN though it is a cover album and EVEN if David didn't mention, that it was indeed Chris'es, it wouldn't matter because this version of the song has already been legally produced and copyrighted under the company he is contracted to work for (or from Chris himself I am unsure in this manner). Regardless of whether David said anything it is still Chris Cornell's song never the less. I am totally sorry for wasting my time and I am sorry for all unecessary insults.

Chris Fri, Mar 28, 2008 at 11:56 PM EST

You know what I am wasting my time... The album as already been produced. I had to re-read the article again to comperhend, I over-reacted and I am terribly sorry. I am a big Audioslave fan and to see anything legally unjust going against to such an awesome band... well one can only help to react in rather direct frustration. The general population is right, HIS VERSION of "Billie Jean" has been legally produced and copyrighted so AS LONG AS THAT version or make of "Billie Jean" is legally under his arm EVEN though it is a cover album and EVEN if David didn't mention, that it was indeed Chris'es, it wouldn't matter because this version of the song has already been legally produced and copyrighted under the company he is contracted to work for (or from Chris himself I am unsure in this manner). Regardless of whether David said anything it is still Chris Cornell's song never the less. I am totally sorry for wasting my time and I am sorry for all unecessary insults.

Chris Sat, Mar 29, 2008 at 12:12 AM EST

Well I guess Chris is going solo then, kind of like Aaron Lewis of Staind (well not really). Hmm... I think for the sake of making the kick azz music that he makes. I really think he should stay with Audioslave. Ahhhh he has gone rebel *sighs* damn. I don't know, not really wise of him but I guess he will make it, kind of hard to go solo like that. I guess he is willing to risk the reputation he has worked to hard to build. Well his name is obviously big so I am sure he will prevail. Need to pick up a copy and listen to the album. The album has been released 06/05/2007 in the U.S. and 05/28/2007 in the U.K. under the production of "Surtone/Interscope" . This is what I mean by legitamite production. AS LONG AS HE HAS produced THIS album FIRST I shouldn't really see what the fuss is all about between David Cook and Chris Cornell. NOW if Chris Cornell was in the process of making his mix of "Billie Jean" and David Cook found out about it at a concert as a sample Chris gave out then....

Chris Sat, Mar 29, 2008 at 12:19 AM EST

...(or rather sung on stage and possiblity David Cook recorded it before Chris had the time to legally produce it THEN... the possiblity and anticipation of a possible legal problem would be apparent NOW WOULD IT BE !!! _. MUWHAAHAHAHAHAHH!!!!!

All is ok, no biggie to all the Chris Cornell loyalists.

anyone Sat, Mar 29, 2008 at 12:25 AM EST

new subject please!

Sam Lim Sat, Mar 29, 2008 at 12:32 AM EST

RULES IS TO CHOOSE THE SONG THE YEAR THEY WERE BORN. However David Cook was born in 1983 but Chris Cornell version of Billie Jean was release on 1987. I think this is kind of CHEATING, I think there is a credibility issue here. I don't like him his kind of sneeky and shrewd and desperate to win American Idol. Simon is right he is kind of cocky kind of person. This is just my opinion and the way I see the whole picture.

shin goon Sat, Mar 29, 2008 at 12:35 AM EST

It's fun to read all these comments. Personally, I have yet to see someone from Season 7 take the stage the way Clay Aiken did each time on Season 2. I am not a Claymate, but if you review his clips on You Tube, you will probably see how he commands the stage and how seemingly effortless he sings. No one in Season 7 even comes close. David Cook might seem the frontrunner now but he'll grow old one day, then what? I don't necessarily see him mesmerizing people 10 years from now. I think the likes of Clay Aiken have more staying power in the business (if they really take care of their careers). Many are blessed with talent, but not everyone is born with fame as his/her twin.

Christ Sat, Mar 29, 2008 at 12:37 AM EST

I think stopped the argument here lol's. So the only point to all the American idol watchers and the Savage Garden/Audioslave/Chris Cornell's solo self is legallity folks. That is all that matters. His version of "Billie Jean" has already been produced and copyrighted. GET IT. GOOD.

P.S. Still paying the mad respects to MJ for old schooler though. YES it is truly MJ's song folks

Christopher Sat, Mar 29, 2008 at 12:42 AM EST

Let us just stop turning this damn argument into another typical internet forum and get on with our personal life's people we are wasting our time. Chris Cornell's VERSION of "Billie Jean" is Chris Cornell's. SO WHAT if David gives creditability or not, it is legally still Chris'es version of the song. So wasting your breath and invest in something more better or productive such as progressing with your lives...

I have fun when I need to but I take my studies seriously. So let us all try to do the same

Sam Lim Sat, Mar 29, 2008 at 12:44 AM EST

CORRECTION: CHRIS CORNELL VERSION OF BILLIE JEAN WAS RELEASE ON 2007 NOT 1987, SORRY FOR THE TYPO AND DAVID COOK WAS BORN YEAR: 1983.

Christopher Crespo Sat, Mar 29, 2008 at 12:59 AM EST

Loving the comment posted by Wikipedia (via.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carry_On_(Chris_Cornell_album))

QUOTE: From Toronto's Globe and Mail, May 22, 2007, "Essential tracks: Billie Jean -- Billie Jean is not his lover, she's just a cover. The plutonium-lunged grunge god ponderously gives the Jacko hit the Leonard Cohen treatment."

"Billie Jean is not his lover, she's just a cover."

Hmm this is so true in todays contemporary relationship soceity your traditional "back in the day" day to day world where people where at the very least more nieve.

Yeah ain't like the old times anymore (-_-)

Lauren Sat, Mar 29, 2008 at 01:05 AM EST

The reason they keep calling David original is.... do you see what he is up against? People that keep performing cookie cutter arrangements that we already know. David brings something new to the table. He takes songs we know and versions we may not be familiar with. He also is a completely new genre of music for idol (sort of emo, sort of hard rock...). 'Music snobs' need to give him credit. He finds and perfects these non-traditional arrangements every week (and Chris Cornell's album sales on Itunes have soared). No other contestant does it.

Vader Sat, Mar 29, 2008 at 01:06 AM EST

Hahaha CLAY AIKEN?? His voice is badly stretched when it comes to certain songs, and he tends to shout a lot. There's no question that the overall standard has increased this season. It's just that people's expectations have also risen. Clay Aiken may not even make the final 24 if he joined this season, certainly not the final 12. But I don't want to derail the topic, so I will say this: none of Clay's performances even come close to David Cook's rendition of 'Billie Jean', copycat or not.

Sat, Mar 29, 2008 at 01:12 AM EST

Clay Aiken is not an American Idol, he is a show tune singer. He should be on broadway and on cruise ships. He is also an arrogant *insert whatever word you like*. Ever since his appearance on Regis and Kelly, I haven't been able to stand him. Stop talking, Clay. No one cares about what you have to say. Shut up and sing. Actually, don't. Just shut up. Maybe he should go host a show for Brave - Project Broadway.

Lauren Sat, Mar 29, 2008 at 01:12 AM EST

*Bravo

Sunny Sat, Mar 29, 2008 at 02:30 AM EST

I just feel sneaky about this guy from the beginning of the show. One day, he was rude and cocky to Simon, and on the very next show, he apologized to him regaining reputation from Simon. Then, he sang "Hello" borrowing someone else's version and never gave credit to the group (Brandon Boyd), then articles revealed the rage of Doxology. Then he found another unknown version of Chris Cornell. His game plan has been working very well until this time, and now everyone is fussing about his integrity as a true musician. At least, previous idols were not sneaky but sincere. I have some sort of eyes to see people but I can't see true David C. Or maybe what I see is what I get. Then, he is not my true idol type. Singing well is important but it is not all. I hope to see more of his integrity and humbleness as well as good singing.

Kath Sat, Mar 29, 2008 at 02:37 AM EST

I don't care what Chris Cornell thinks; David Cook is still a smug jerk.

Azi Sat, Mar 29, 2008 at 04:00 AM EST

Urgh, I wish people would just can it with the “He stole whose version”. Obviously it has got to be someone’s version at one point or another. It’s a singing competition. You’re supposed to be judging his voice and his performance. He just has a knack for choosing songs ( or ‘versions’) which suits his rocker style.

From Singapore here. Fan of the show. Huge fan of David Cook. Damn, I wish I could vote…

anti-clueless Sat, Mar 29, 2008 at 05:09 AM EST

Sunny: David didn't do Brandon Boyd's version of Hello. Listen to them both. They're different. David gave credit to Doxology for Eleanor Rigby, but it was cut from the show. David acknowledged Chris Cornell, but the judges ignored it. And maybe he apologized to Simon because he felt bad, yes? This isn't David's fault, it's American Idols fault. Good article about the judges here: http://www.castrocopia.com/index.php?catid=18&blogid=1

Sally in Chicago Sat, Mar 29, 2008 at 06:23 AM EST

Mandia "I'm Every Woman" - a cover of Chaka Khan
Rami "Alone" - a cover of Carrie Underwood, Carly and Heart

So let's get on with it folks....these kids are not experts, they don't arrange their own songs...they take their cues from Ricky Minor who probably has a large input about the arrangement.
David C. did good; I learned who Chris Connell was -- and thanks for reminding me he did the theme to Casino Royale (hated the theme!), and Chris Connell was have millions of downloads because of DC and Idol.

Bev Sat, Mar 29, 2008 at 06:26 AM EST

I'd also never heard of Chris Cornell before so I've made a great discovery, thanks to David Cook. All of them are doing covers and covers of covers, so there's nothing for Chris's fans to get so heated up about. Especially since the cover was credited to Chris beforehand. It's not the fact that he did this cover that's so amazing, it's the way he did it and the fact that he was so darn good at it! Try and imagine one of the other idols, from almost any season, trying this cover. They'd all look ridiculous. I was blown away by David Cook's performance! Totally amazing!

jason Sat, Mar 29, 2008 at 07:13 AM EST

Love can make people mature. I lost my girlfriend. Someone online told me a site wealthyloves.c o m. He said that i can

date girl here. Is it useful?

Ryan Sat, Mar 29, 2008 at 07:37 AM EST

Can we all end this stupid convo now?
Thank you.
Seacrest out.

Ed Sat, Mar 29, 2008 at 09:29 AM EST

I have been a fan of Chris Cornell and Soundgarden since 1992. I saw Chris perform at Cains ballroom in Tulsa last year and I was totally blown away. My friend and I remarked to each other that it had to be one of the top five shows we had ever seen and we've seen hundreds. He is absolutely one of the greatest performers and vocalists of all time. The electricity and emotion he exudes live is like no other. I am very happy for him and really glad he is getting exposed to so many new fans due to the performance by David Cook.

Cindi Sat, Mar 29, 2008 at 09:32 AM EST

First of all the song came out in 1982 it doesn't matter when the arrangement was created. Chris Cornell has no rights except the right to ask Michael Jackson if he can sing his song. David gave him credit for the arrangement but he did not sing it note for note following every vocal nuance. Chris Cornell, Soundgarden and Audioslave were not exactly household names before this and now everyone is talking. So this was nothing but good for Chris Cornell. He has a future star singing his songs in front of a national audience and I bet there a lot of musicians who would love to have David sing their song so they could get their names out there. People saying David copied Brandon Boyd are just ignorant. There is not any similarity at all between the two versions of Hello besides the fact that it was Lionel Richie's song. David completely changed that up and did not need to give Incubus credit. David is making Missouri proud so give him his props and let him enjoy the ride.

lyn1792 Sat, Mar 29, 2008 at 09:39 AM EST

I've read the comments and bottom line - David Cook has a set of pipes on him that few can match. Never heard of Chris Cornell and didn't hear Seacrest say "Chris Cornell" however it only stands to reason that someone else had to come up with this version of Billie Jean (never heard it before either and was blown away). Took abit of research to see who was the creator of it and found Chris Cornell. This has not been a negative experience for CC: his name is jumping all over the place. Listened to him sing BJ on YT and in reality: David Cook does a much more dynamic version but CC does an excellent job also. Michael Jackson should sell the rights to Chris Cornell and let David Cook sing it. Get over yourselves and root for individuals that have talent. Simon Cowell by the way is dead on every time he speaks.....

Sharon66 Sat, Mar 29, 2008 at 09:51 AM EST

For me, the issue is not his choice to do the particular cover, it was the slobbering praise he got from the judges for being "daring" and taking a "risk". A cover is a risk? Since when is there anything original about that. On the other hand, David Archuleta took an actual risk by choosing a cover that was relatively unknown to the judges. What happens? He got panned for singing something they didn't know. I think the judges REEK on the subject of song choice. Their comments on pitch and performance ability are usually relevant. But their personal opinions about song choice make me cringe!

ln1792 Sat, Mar 29, 2008 at 10:00 AM EST

You know Sharon, there is a measure of truth in what your saying especially when they do the selecting of the music "Beatles" for 2 weeks in a row and then due to redundance, the singers get creamed because the "beatle" night had been exhausted...bottome line it is only opinion. I hear you about David Archuleta version of an unknown song - but he didn't do a very good job on it anyway. I hadn't heard the song and thought..."what is this" - the mass rules in this program. I went back again and watched DC on YT singing BJ and came to the conclusion that in reality it is Michael Jacksons song - how does he feel about the performance, I would be interested in knowing that. CC was given the credit regarding version

Judi Sat, Mar 29, 2008 at 10:20 AM EST

First of all, David Cook is highly over-rated. He could never sing as good as Chris Cornell (no one can). I think he has some pair on him trying to attempt to sing a song by CC. Chris Cornell has the complete package - excellent voice and he is a very beautiful man. I think David Cook thinks he's a lot better than he really is. I wouldn't buy any of his records, the voice is just not good enough.

kw Sat, Mar 29, 2008 at 10:50 AM EST

david cook can blow but there is only one cornell...best male rock voice alive!! we need to relax, they said it was a cornell arrangement at the beginning.

Leila Sat, Mar 29, 2008 at 11:14 AM EST

Ryan did introduce the song as Chris Cornell's cover, but the judges didn't seem to hear it (it was loud in there with all the screams and applause). It was clear to me neither of the judges knew Chris Cornell's version, because they all praised Cook for his originality without comparing it to Cornell's singing. They usually do it by pointing out, for instance, if the contestant measured up (or not) to "Celine Dion's version" or "Whitney Houston's version". None of the judges seem to have that much musical culture beyond the cheesy pop stuff, because in every episode they say they didn't know a song that was pretty much a hit either at the 70's or 80's (and those guys are older than me, so if I know the songs, they should know them too).

Dave Sat, Mar 29, 2008 at 11:42 AM EST

Hey people, I think anyone who watches American Idol, or reality TV in general, is a mindless friggin' drone. Please comment "drones".

Now a New Fan Sat, Mar 29, 2008 at 12:04 PM EST

What people tend to forget is it brought free publicity to Chris (and other artist) and put them out in front of --Oh—What!!!---maybe millions of new people!!!!

David pulled it off smashingly.

Ryan introduced it as Chris Cornell’s rendition---I immediately got on the internet when David finished singing the song to see what other songs Chris had out there. They will soon be in my collection. Now I am a fan of Chris Cornell’s, love his voice and I probably wouldn’t of known about him until David sang his cover.

AND I am a fan of David’s and am looking forward to hearing his first single!!!

saywhat? Sat, Mar 29, 2008 at 12:18 PM EST

"Cindi - Chris Cornell, Soundgarden and Audioslave were not exactly household names before this and now everyone is talking."

Sure they were. Anyone who's listened to alternative rock in the last 15-20 years knows these names very well.

Steve Klemetti Sat, Mar 29, 2008 at 12:40 PM EST

My question is: Who is Chris Cornell?

Shouldn't one be famous before considering someone doing a remake of his song. It is Michael Jackson's until the one who remakes it is famous.

Doug Sat, Mar 29, 2008 at 12:46 PM EST

Sounds like sour grapes. Thirty-some years ago I was a fan of an unknown bar band called "Boston". I was bummed when they became huge because they were no longer a group that I could introduce others to. CC Fans should be glad that their "fav" got this much exposure. Also, just because I never heard of Chris Cornell before doesn't make me ignorant. After I heard DC's performance I replayed the intro, and listened to CC's version on YouTube. I bought his ITunes version and will buy his new CD next month. As for David Cooke, he is incredibly original in knowing his "style" and selecting arrangements that are perfect for him. Any idiot can sing a karoke version of an original song. CC is a genius but I can guarantee he didn't create the arrangement, record it and perform it in six days, so cut Cooke a little slack about originality.

I heard Chris Cornell on Ryan's radio show and he is a real class act. Is all this exposure good for Chris's income? - you bet - He Got My Money!

Artie Sat, Mar 29, 2008 at 01:35 PM EST

I agree with many of the other folks posting, Cook too a chance by covering this song and it never seemed as if he was taking credit for the arrangement. I now am a Chris Cornell fan, so it seems like a win-win situation for all. Too much being put into the so called "controversy" of all of this.

_Me2 Sat, Mar 29, 2008 at 02:08 PM EST

"It was clear to me [that] he was a big fan as he followed my arrangement down to the T, including the most subtle vocal nuances."

It's obvious that even Chris C thought that David Cook copied him and DIDN'T bring anything new. Shouldn't Chris know? He did the arrangement? AI judges - stop with the 'originality' and 'brave' comments for David C. coz he didn't deserve it. Chris C's version is so full of raw emotion...that David C did not and could not convey.

vw Sat, Mar 29, 2008 at 02:46 PM EST

okay ppl, we all know Randy and Paula are vocabulary challenged. i will fall over the day they stop using the same 10 words to describe a performance, good or bad. they use the word original everytime they hear something they haven't heard alot or at all from the contestants. we all know what the word original means in the dictionary. in this case, with these two it's totally up for grabs. when they learn new words maybe you'll be happier.

To Steve Klemetti Sat, Mar 29, 2008 at 04:24 PM EST

Who wrote: "My question is: Who is Chris Cornell? Shouldn't one be famous before considering someone doing a remake of his song." Um, excuse me? The man has been recording for over 20 years, and his work with Soundgarden is considered the bedrock foundation of the Seattle grunge music phenomenon of the 1990s. Without Chris Cornell, there would be no Pearl Jam, no Nirvana, the list goes on... A singing and writing rock pioneer who has been nominated for multiple Grammy awards, won multiple Grammy awards, sold over 20 million records, been recording for over 20 years and has managed to stay relevant (he did the